I’ve added the nine movies that Tom Rothman picked in his Criterion Closet appearance:

Down By Law
To Be or Not to Be
Harlan County USA
Winchester '73
To Sleep with Anger
The Ice Storm
The Big Chill
The Philadelphia Story

Tom Rothman made no original picks, but his commentary for each pick was outstanding. This is why my Master List of Closet Picks in the Criterion Closet is so valuable.